The main problem I have with yesterday’s video is that I’m pretty sure the scenarios he gets into at the end are right. Â For the most part, I have remained neutral on Xbox achievements. Â I like getting them, but rarely do I ever spend time playing a game in a manner I do not enjoy just for an achievement. Â For example, there is one in the game Assassin’s Creed for watching all the “glitches” and while playing I did try to hit my button when I noticed a glitch but at the end of the game I didn’t have that achievement because I had obviously missed one. Â There is also one for getting all the flags, and while I loved noticing and finding flags while playing, when I got to the end I didn’t have them all. Â I loved playing the game, it was fun, but when I finished I did not go back and try to finish off these achievements. Â I know some people who cannot leave a game until they’ve gotten every single one.
On the other hand, I have a credit card with a rewards program and I use the card at every single opportunity in order to not miss out on the free points which turn into free gifts later. Â So for me, the dividing line appears to be virtual rewards versus real rewards. Â If Xbox achievements came with Xbox Live points that I could use to buy items from the Marketplace, I’d probably spend more time trying to get them all.
After watching the video, I thought to myself, “You know, sometimes I do forget to brush my teeth. Would I remember it every day if I earned points for doing it?” Â I do brush my teeth with fair regularity, enough that I don’t have cavities or other teeth issues (partly, I suspect, this is due to habits I formed while having braces on my teeth for almost 5 years, the manner in which I eat and the amount of licking, probing and sucking I do throughout the day keeps food particles from settling between my teeth and in my gums), but if brushing every day earned me some “free stuff” then I have to admit, I probably would do it every day.
Do I want to see point systems and rewards on everything? Â Not really. Â But I do expect it to come. Â I just hope that the power to manipulate behavior with games is handled with some care as it invades more aspects of life.
“I just hope that the power to manipulate behavior with games is handled with some care as it invades more aspects of life.”
Agreed… though I’ll admit I’m not terribly optimistic that it will be. The picture Schell paints is… troubling, especially if Big Brother governments get involved.
I have hope. I lack faith.